What Should Small Business Owners Consider for their First Major Hire?

    Authored By

    Small Biz Leader

    What Should Small Business Owners Consider for their First Major Hire?

    Navigating the complexities of a first major hire can be a defining moment for small business owners. From focusing on core values and vision to setting clear hiring goals and stages, we've compiled insights from nine seasoned CEOs and marketing leaders. Discover the invaluable lessons they learned from their initial hiring experiences.

    • Focus on Core Values and Vision
    • Seek Well-Rounded, Cultural Fits
    • Inventory Skills and Embrace Versatility
    • Find Passionate Candidates with Shared Vision
    • Define the Role with Clear Expectations
    • Prioritize Team Vision and Cultural Fit
    • Balance Expertise with Cultural Alignment
    • Assemble a Support Team and Use Offer Letters
    • Set Clear Hiring Goals and Stages

    Focus on Core Values and Vision

    The approach was cautious yet optimistic. Recognizing the significance of our first major hire—someone who would set the tone for the company culture and help shape our future—I focused on alignment with our core values and vision more than on impeccable résumés or extensive experience.

    We advertised the position, emphasizing the need for passion and a pioneering spirit as much as skills and qualifications. During interviews, I concentrated on understanding the candidates' motivations, their adaptability, and how they handle challenges, rather than just their technical abilities. This process was about finding a collaborator, not just an employee.

    From this experience, I learned the invaluable lesson that hiring should be a holistic process. The right first hire should not only possess the skills needed but also share the company’s vision and be ready to grow with the business. This taught me that sometimes, attitude and potential are as important as experience.

    Niclas Schlopsna
    Niclas SchlopsnaManaging Consultant and CEO, spectup

    Seek Well-Rounded, Cultural Fits

    As an inexperienced CEO, my first significant hire was both nerve-wracking and exciting. I initially placed the utmost importance on technical skills and past experience. However, through this process, I came to understand that there's more to an employee than just their resume. Their drive, adaptability, and alignment with our company culture also play an instrumental role. Now, I focus on finding well-rounded individuals who bring more than professional competencies to the table. Hiring, to me, is not just about filling a post but about positively impacting our journey.

    Abid Salahi
    Abid SalahiCo-founder & CEO, FinlyWealth

    Inventory Skills and Embrace Versatility

    When looking to make your first major hire, I did an inventory of our current capabilities and the capabilities the business needed in order to continue to grow to the next level. When identifying existing gaps, this helped form the basis of the job description, coupled with the vision of the company and the type of person that would buy into this vision. This forms the profile of the person you will be working with.

    Keep in mind, if they are your first major hire, they should be willing and excited about being versatile in their new role. Sometimes you need to wear multiple hats, and this person must be versatile but certainly have areas of focus.

    It's a great advantage if they have previously worked in small organizations and helped them succeed, but if they don't have experience with startups, you should make sure they know what to expect as you may not have everything figured out yet and will need their assistance to get there. Above all else, you need to get along with the person, and they need a solid work ethic to make this work.

    Sam McNaull
    Sam McNaullCEO, LNine Consulting Inc.

    Find Passionate Candidates with Shared Vision

    As a small-business owner, my approach to my first major hire was to focus on finding someone who not only had the right skills and experience but also shared the same passion and vision for the company. I learned that it's important not to rush the hiring process and to take the time to find the right fit for your team. Building a strong team is crucial for the success of your business, so don't settle for just anyone—wait for the right person who will help take your company to the next level. Trust me, it's worth the wait!

    Alex Stasiak
    Alex StasiakCEO & Founder, Startup House

    Define the Role with Clear Expectations

    Our goal is to determine whether we are a good fit for the person and whether the person is a good match for us. In addition, you must understand which personality traits and behaviors are treatable and which are lethal or incurable in your specific setting.

    Although your employee may need to wear various hats, it is still critical to explicitly define the function before beginning the hiring process. This will provide clarity while aiding in the recruitment of qualified candidates.

    Create a detailed job description outlining your first employee's future high-level responsibilities and day-to-day tasks. Make sure you are reasonable with your criteria and aren't trying to shoehorn the tasks of three different roles into one.

    Tristan Harris
    Tristan HarrisDemand Generation Senior Marketing Manager, Thrive Digital Marketing Agency

    Prioritize Team Vision and Cultural Fit

    In my first major hiring process, I focused on finding people who fit the team's vision and culture. Technical skills are important, but I thought teamwork and a passion for innovation were more important. Through the interview process, we tried to gain an in-depth understanding of the candidates' values and motivations. Through this experience, I learned that recruiting the right talent is key to organizational growth, and that fit with team culture should be a top priority.

    Alex Taylor
    Alex TaylorHead of Marketing, CrownTV

    Balance Expertise with Cultural Alignment

    Approaching my first major hire, I defined clear criteria for the role. I drafted an outline of specific responsibilities, necessary skills, and qualities essential for success. I conducted thorough interviews, evaluated candidates based on their qualifications and cultural fit, and sought input from trusted colleagues.

    Throughout the process, I learned the importance of balancing technical expertise with cultural alignment and communication skills. I also realized the significance of investing time in onboarding and providing ongoing support to help new hires integrate smoothly into the team. Overall, this experience taught me the value of strategic hiring practices and the critical role of hiring decisions in shaping organizational culture and success.

    Khunshan Ahmad
    Khunshan AhmadCEO, InsideTechWorld

    Assemble a Support Team and Use Offer Letters

    Here's what I learned from my experience: Before making your first major hire, it's wise to assemble a support team. You might feel pressed for time, eager to cut costs, or hear advice like what my brother-in-law gave me, suggesting that all these steps aren't necessary. However, you really do need a team of service providers. It's important to find a knowledgeable business lawyer, a trustworthy accountant or accounting firm, and check with local universities to see if they offer business assistance programs.

    Every business should have a relationship with a lawyer. A cost-effective way to start this is by having your attorney help you draft a standard "offer letter" template. An offer letter clarifies any misunderstandings. It spells out exactly what you are offering to a job candidate, regardless of what they might have thought they heard during the interview. Details such as confirming that they won't have to travel more than 20% of the time, and that travel times are unpaid and don't count toward overtime, should be clearly stated in writing. Speaking from experience, I can say that having solid offer letters is critical. Lawsuits can happen unexpectedly for any number of reasons. Using offer letters is one way to lessen your risks.

    Michael Brown
    Michael BrownManaging Partner, Dribbin & Brown Criminal Lawyers

    Set Clear Hiring Goals and Stages

    The first major hire is a nerve-racking experience for any business owner/founder. The best approach is to set clear goals for your hiring requirements and establish the different stages of hiring well before you start announcing the openings. This will give you the required leverage to get the best team for your organization. Also, establish an 'FAQ by Candidates' so that you are prepared to answer some of the uncomfortable questions with clarity and confidence. An unambiguous hiring process will instill confidence in the candidates and build lasting trust for the organization.

    Mittu Tigi
    Mittu TigiStartup Ecosystem Enabler